The Quick Answer
Choose aluminum if you want an open view, the look of wrought iron, a pool fence, or a front-yard fence. Choose vinyl if privacy is the main goal.
Side by Side
| Aluminum | Vinyl | |
|---|---|---|
| Look | Wrought-iron style, open | Solid, clean panels |
| Privacy | Low; you can see through | High with privacy panels |
| Maintenance | Almost none; never rusts | Almost none; occasional wash |
| Pools | Excellent; see-through and rust-free | Works where privacy matters |
| Slopes | Panels can often rack to follow the ground | Usually stepped down slopes |
| Wind | Wind passes through | Solid panels catch wind; posts must be set well |
| HOAs | Very commonly approved | Often approved for backyards |
| Colors | Black, bronze, white and more | White, tan and earth tones |
When Aluminum Wins
- You want to define the yard but keep the view
- You need a pool fence
- You want a front-yard fence that adds curb appeal
- Your yard slopes and you want the fence to follow the ground
- Your HOA requires an open style
See 2-rail and 3-rail aluminum fence.
When Vinyl Wins
- You want privacy from neighbors or a busy street
- You want a quiet, enclosed patio or pool area
- Your dog barks at everything it can see
See vinyl fence.
The best of both: Many West County yards get vinyl privacy along the back property line and aluminum along the sides and front. We can quote it as one project.
Common Questions
Which lasts longer, aluminum or vinyl?
Both are long-lasting. Quality powder-coated aluminum often lasts for decades, and quality vinyl commonly lasts 20 to 30 years or more. Neither rots or needs paint.
Which is better for dogs?
Both work. Aluminum with puppy pickets suits most dogs and lets them see out. Vinyl privacy fence is better for dogs that bark at everything they see.
Which is easier to get approved by an HOA?
It depends on the HOA, but open aluminum fence is one of the most commonly approved styles. Some HOAs allow vinyl privacy only in backyards. Check your guidelines.
Can I use both?
Yes, and many homeowners do: vinyl privacy along the back where neighbors are close, aluminum on the sides and front to keep things open.